Do Self-Help Books Actually Work? Here are 3 Alternatives
Share this content :
Self help books are known as one of the fastest-growing nonfiction genres in the United States of America, expected to grow to $14 billion in sales by 2025. The popularity of the genre is clear as day, but is the hype really worth it? This article reveals why this genre may not be as insightful as you may think.
The Help in Self-Help Books
The purpose of self help books appears to be straightforward. These are books with helpful advice that viewers can apply for themselves on their own volition and timing. However, this raises questions on how exactly it compares to therapy sessions with active guidance. While these books are widely accessible and more affordable than therapy, the question remains: are people truly getting the help they need by relying solely on self help books?
Medical professionals believe that self help books have commendable illustrations and affirmations that help people in two different ways: shifting perspectives and validating personal outlooks. These books expose the possibilities, encouraging you to move forward. It also validates your views in thoughtful and memorable quotations. Reading these books builds a hopeful and confident mindset, yet critics remain skeptical.
Self-Help Books Need Help Too
Despite the mass appeal, self help books face criticism for presenting exaggerated, generic, and impractical advice. Behind the marketing hype, broad and simplistic ideas from these books undermine the nuance of personal growth. Readers struggle to grasp certain concepts, especially if they are impaired by trauma or mental illnesses.
Critics also question the writers’ qualifications regarding their research and experience, emphasizing the need for clinical trials to test the self help books. At the same time, not every reader resonates with medical approaches. Ultimately, the reader bears the responsibility, which can be harmful if they are impressionable and fail to select wise suggestions based on their situation.
The Self in Self-Help Books
Reading books provides valuable knowledge at the flip of a page, but real-life experiences have a greater impact on learning. Along with other people’s inspirational stories, your story matters too. Here are 3 alternatives to self help books that place your experience at the center:
1. Talking It Out
Reading carefully written text removes the human connection you get from directly talking to another individual. Receiving the words in person involves non-verbal communication that self help books lack. Sharing also creates an interactive experience where you can receive real-time input.
2. Processing on Your Own
Independently processing your emotions gives you more freedom to explore and reflect. Self-help books primarily explain rather than actively help you process. Take the time to sit with your feelings and work through your emotions on your own.
To learn more about how to turn self-reflection into a habit, consider reading “Atomic Habits: An Easy & Proven Way to Build Good Habits & Break Bad Ones” by James Clear.
3. Diversifying Self-care
Reading self help books is just one aspect of personal growth. Diversify your self-care with a mix of passive and engaging activities such as watching a movie, taking a walk, learning a hobby, or eating healthily. This prevents you from relying on just one measure of self-care.
Moving Forward
Self help books still hold merit despite concerns and criticism. However, the books will not truly help you without your participation as the reader. These books serve as a template to gauge what you can and cannot control. Moving forward, read self help books with a nuanced perspective, acceptance of your imperfections, and the ability to filter out unhelpful suggestions.
For books that serve practical solutions and advice, watch our video on “The Ultimate List of Books for Personal Transformation To Revolutionize Your Life!”
Key Takeaways
- Self help books make readers feel optimistic and validated, but irresponsible reading can lead to struggle and failure.
- Instead of reading these books, consider real-life experiences such as having conversations with others, reflecting on your own thoughts, or engaging in other self-care activities.
- Read any self help book with nuance by embracing your imperfections and filtering out unhelpful advice.
Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. Clicking on these links and buying these products may result in us receiving a commission at no additional cost.
Bates, A. (n.d.). Do self-help books offer a remedy or a delusion?. University of Washington Magazine. Retrieved September 23, 2024.
Carey, T. (2020, December 18). Why are self-help books not so helpful after all?. Psychology Today. Retrieved September 23, 2024.
Chui, J. (2022, October 11). Do self-help books actually help?. Medium. Retrieved September 23, 2024.
Goddard, E. (2024, July 1). Self-help was meant to make me feel better. Instead it turned toxic – and borderline dangerous. The Guardian. Retrieved September 23, 2024.
Hendley, S. (n.d.). Can self-help books actually help?. Harper’s Bazaar. Retrieved September 23, 2024.
Kraaijenbrink, J. (2019, July 5). Why self-help books don’t work (and how to nevertheless benefit from them). Forbes. Retrieved September 23, 2024.
Sabado, D. (2023, June 14). Here are some interesting statistics on self-help books. Medium. Retrieved September 24, 2024.
Share this content :
Being successful as a person can both be learned and taught, but you must have the willingness to overcome obstacles and create habits that will make you more successful . I will give you the systems that will do both.
Copyright © 2023 Munif Ali. All rights reserved.
